How does Timor-Leste justify withdrawals above sustainable income?
Short answer: Timor-Leste justifies withdrawals above the Estimated Sustainable Income by submitting specified information and a detailed explanation to Parliament under Article 9 of the Petroleum Fund Law[1]. The government must explain why exceeding this benchmark serves the long-term interests of the country[1]. Parliament must then approve the government justification to allow the excess transfer[2].
Legal Requirements for Excess Withdrawals
The Petroleum Fund Law integrates the fund into the State Budget and requires it to operate openly and transparently[1]. Article 9 of the law prohibits transfers from the Petroleum Fund that exceed the Estimated Sustainable Income in a fiscal year unless the government first provides required information to Parliament[1]. Among these statutory conditions, the government must provide a detailed explanation showing why the excess withdrawal serves the long-term interests of Timor-Leste[1].
Withdrawals from the fund are guided by an Estimated Sustainable Income set at 3% of petroleum wealth[2]. To exceed this level, Parliament must approve the explanation provided by the government regarding the long-term interest of the nation[2]. During the drafting of the framework, La'o Hamutuk proposed limiting above-sustainable transfers to extraordinary reasons and banning them for more than two consecutive years[3]. La'o Hamutuk also noted that the finance ministry rejected a requirement for a separate parliamentary act for each transfer[3].
Government Arguments and Historical Withdrawals
Official justifications have relied on Article 9 to argue that transfers above the benchmark advance national development[4]. In one formal letter, Prime Minister Kay Rala Xanana Gusmão stated that disciplined spending in productive sectors can be balanced with saving for future generations[4]. The argument maintained that fund capital remains abstract to citizens until it is invested directly into infrastructure, agriculture, human capital, and social services[4].
Historical data shows extensive use of these excess transfers[2]. Through 2017, Timor-Leste withdrew $9,633 million from the fund, which was $3,600 million above the cumulative Estimated Sustainable Income[2]. These withdrawals averaged about 5% of petroleum wealth compared to the 3% benchmark set by the Estimated Sustainable Income[2].
"Thus, in accordance with Article 9 of the of the Petroleum Fund Law, this letter comes to justify the need for these funds for the long-term interests of Timor-Leste and its people, and soon we will submit a detailed report on the impact of transferring a larger amount on the ESI calculation for future years."
Related questions
- What alternative withdrawal rule has NBIM proposed for Norway's fund?
- How do Ghana's Stabilisation and Heritage Funds get funded and capped?
- How does Norway's petroleum revenue flow into its fund?
- How are Nigeria's Stabilisation and Future Generations Funds invested?
The sources behind this answer
Frequently asked questions
What is the baseline withdrawal rate for the Petroleum Fund?
Withdrawals are guided by an Estimated Sustainable Income benchmark of 3% of petroleum wealth[2].
Who must approve withdrawals that exceed the sustainable income benchmark?
Parliament must approve the government justification showing that the excess transfer serves the long-term interests of Timor-Leste[1][2].
How much did Timor-Leste withdraw above the benchmark through 2017?
Timor-Leste withdrew $9,633 million through 2017, which was $3,600 million above the cumulative Estimated Sustainable Income[2].
Sources
- Law 2005 09 Petroleum Fund Law, as of 2005
- Petroleum Fund of Timor-Leste Annual Report 2017, as of August 2018
- LH submission on Petroleum Fund Act, as of March 1, 2005
- Prime Minister's letter to the President of Parliament on transfer above the Estimated Sustainable Income (unofficial translation), as of May 31, 2010
Talk to Richard
Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes SovereignWealthFunds.com. If you are a fund manager, capital raiser or family office and want to talk through how sovereign wealth funds work, reach out to him directly.
- Email: richard@familyoffices.com
- Text: (808) 600-9260
- WhatsApp: (808) 600-9260
Disclaimer
Informational only. SovereignWealthFunds.com is an independent public-source reference. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fund named on it, and it is not investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as of the dates shown next to them and may have changed; please read each fund's official pages, linked on its profile. To report an error, use the contact page. Copyright SovereignWealthFunds.com. All rights reserved.
