What alternative withdrawal rule has NBIM proposed for Norway's fund?

Short answer: NBIM proposed an alternative rule that links withdrawals to GDP and the business cycle instead of fund value[1]. This proposal lowers average withdrawals over time to reduce the risk of fund depletion[1]. It addresses the mismatch between expected return spending and cyclical deficit funding[1].

Details of the proposed alternative rule

NBIM outlined an alternative withdrawal rule for Norway's Government Pension Fund Global[1]. Under this proposed rule, withdrawals are tied directly to GDP and the business cycle rather than the overall value of the fund[1]. The alternative rule also lowers average withdrawals over time[1]. This reduction in average withdrawals is designed to reduce the risk of depleting the fund[1].

The proposal followed a simulation conducted by NBIM[1]. In this study, NBIM simulated the fund and the Norwegian budget together[1]. The simulation examined the trade off between the two aims of the fiscal spending rule[1]. Through this work, the organization analyzed how fund withdrawals interact with the national budget across different economic conditions[1].

Issues identified with counter cyclical spending

NBIM observed that spending in line with expected returns does not match the withdrawals needed to fund cyclical deficits in Norway[1]. Counter cyclical spending creates specific funding requirements that differ from returns[1]. When withdrawals are used to accommodate counter cyclical spending, the probability of depleting the fund real value over the long term increases[1].

The trade off between spending aims prompted the study of new withdrawal mechanics[1]. The existing approach of spending expected returns does not align with cyclical budget needs[1]. Tying withdrawals to GDP and economic cycles offers a different structure[1]. By lowering the average withdrawal level over time, the alternative rule aims to mitigate the long term depletion risk associated with counter cyclical demands[1].

Frequently asked questions

What does the proposed alternative rule tie withdrawals to?

The proposed rule ties withdrawals to GDP and the business cycle rather than the fund value[1].

Why does counter cyclical spending pose a risk to the fund?

Using withdrawals to fund counter cyclical spending raises the probability of depleting the real value of the fund over the long term[1].

What did NBIM simulate to study the fiscal spending rule?

NBIM simulated the fund and the Norwegian budget to study the trade off between the two aims of the fiscal spending rule[1].

Sources
  1. Norway’s NBIM outlines alternative rule for GPFG withdrawals - European Pensions

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes SovereignWealthFunds.com. If you are a fund manager, capital raiser or family office and want to talk through how sovereign wealth funds work, reach out to him directly.

Disclaimer

Informational only. SovereignWealthFunds.com is an independent public-source reference. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fund named on it, and it is not investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as of the dates shown next to them and may have changed; please read each fund's official pages, linked on its profile. To report an error, use the contact page. Copyright SovereignWealthFunds.com. All rights reserved.