How do NSIA and Guyana protect funds from political pressure?

Short answer: A Wilson Center summary reports that NSIA relies on an independent board with professional experience to enforce rules on government requests for funds[1]. NSIA rests on a 2011 Act passed by the National Assembly[2]. Guyana's Natural Resource Fund divides duties between the Ministry of Finance and the Bank of Guyana[3]. Two authors caution that future Guyanese governments could still use the fund for short term political gain[4].

How NSIA is set up

NSIA's self assessment for 2022 states that the fund rests on the NSIA (Establishment etc.) Act 2011[2]. The National Assembly passed the Act[2]. It was signed on 26 May 2011[2].

A Wilson Center summary from June 2016 reports Orji's view of the board[1]. The summary says the board is independent and has professional experience[1]. It says the board sits outside Nigeria's fiscal framework[1]. The summary describes this board as integral to enforcing rules on government requests for funds[1].

How Guyana's fund is organized

IFSWF describes the Natural Resource Fund as using a manager model[3]. The Ministry of Finance holds overall responsibility[3]. The Bank of Guyana handles operational management[3]. It does so under an investment mandate and an operational agreement[3].

Risks noted by Ali and Schena

Ali and Schena wrote about a possible sovereign wealth fund for Guyana in May 2017[4]. They caution that future Guyanese governments could use the fund for short term political gain[4]. They say the fund's impact depends entirely on the commitment of those governments to its mission[4].

Ali and Schena also address a possible domestic infrastructure mandate[4]. If Guyana gives the fund that mandate, they say governance must be designed carefully[4]. The aim is to avoid unaccountable streams outside the budget that worsen the resource curse[4].

Fund profiles mentioned

The sources behind this answer

When the sources behind this answer were publishedWhen the 3 sources behind this answer were published120161201712022Count of cited sources by year of publication. Full list in Sources below.

Frequently asked questions

What law is NSIA based on?

NSIA rests on the NSIA (Establishment etc.) Act 2011[2]. The National Assembly passed the Act, and it was signed on 26 May 2011[2].

Who runs Guyana's Natural Resource Fund?

The Ministry of Finance holds overall responsibility[3]. The Bank of Guyana handles operational management[3].

What do Ali and Schena say about political use of Guyana's fund?

They caution that future Guyanese governments could use the fund for short term political gain[4]. They also say governance of any domestic infrastructure mandate must be designed carefully[4].

Sources
  1. Long-term Sustainable Development in Africa: The Role of Sovereign Wealth Funds, as of June 14, 2016
  2. Santiago Principles Self-Assessment: NSIA 2022, as of 2022
  3. Natural Resource Fund | IFSWF
  4. Harnessing Oil Wealth in Guyana via a Sovereign Wealth Fund: Look Before You Leap, as of May 2017

Talk to Richard

Richard C. Wilson founded the Family Office Club and publishes SovereignWealthFunds.com. If you are a fund manager, capital raiser or family office and want to talk through how sovereign wealth funds work, reach out to him directly.

Disclaimer

Informational only. SovereignWealthFunds.com is an independent public-source reference. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by any fund named on it, and it is not investment, legal or tax advice. Figures are as of the dates shown next to them and may have changed; please read each fund's official pages, linked on its profile. To report an error, use the contact page. Copyright SovereignWealthFunds.com. All rights reserved.